From Kafka vendor lock-in to open-source: less costs, more flexibility, and independence

Apache Kafka has become a cornerstone for organizations building robust, real-time data platforms. While vendor-locked implementations often provide an easy entry point, more companies are shifting to open-source Kafka to achieve greater flexibility, reduce costs, and maintain control over their data infrastructure.

At Axual, we’ve worked with organizations across industries, including energy, finance, and telecommunications, to guide them on this journey. This transition from vendor lock-in to open-source is a powerful way to foster innovation and independence, but it also comes with its own challenges.

In this post, we’ll explore the benefits of open-source Kafka, real-world examples of its use, and the obstacles organizations must address when making the switch.

The case for open-source Kafka

‍Moving from a vendor lock-in implementation to open-source offers several compelling advantages:

• Cost Savings: Eliminating licensing fees frees up innovation, infrastructure, and operational scaling budgets.
• Architectural Flexibility: Open-source Kafka allows complete customization to meet specific business needs without being tied to a vendor’s roadmap.
• Collaboration: By removing licensing restrictions, organizations can more easily share data and collaborate with partners and internal teams.
• Independence: Organizations retain complete control over their Kafka architecture, ensuring adaptability in a rapidly evolving technological landscape.
• Scalability: Kafka’s modular architecture enables seamless scaling and integration of new use cases or capabilities.

These benefits make open-source Kafka a compelling choice for organizations looking to future-proof their data infrastructure and innovate more freely.

Challenges of transitioning from vendor lock-in to open-source Kafka

‍While the benefits are significant, organizations must address key challenges when transitioning to open-source:

1. Lack of Vendor Support
   Open-source Kafka does not come with built-in vendor support for troubleshooting or incident resolution. Organizations must develop internal expertise or partner with external support providers to manage and maintain the platform effectively.
2. Operational Complexity
   Maintaining and upgrading Kafka clusters requires significant effort, including performance monitoring, resource scaling, and ensuring high availability. Teams must also be prepared to assist with tasks like topic creation, access management, and certificate updates.
3. Governance and Security
   Managing access permissions, ensuring compliance, and maintaining robust security are more complex in open-source environments. Organizations need clear policies and tools to govern their Kafka usage effectively.
4. User Accessibility
   Unlike vendor-provided solutions, open-source Kafka lacks a user-friendly interface, which can slow adoption across teams without strong Kafka expertise. Training and enablement are critical to addressing this gap.
5. Knowledge Gap
   Organizations accustomed to vendor-managed solutions often face a steep learning curve when transitioning to open-source Kafka. Building expertise in Kafka architecture, event design, and troubleshooting requires significant investment in training and recruitment.
6. Collaboration Across Teams or Partners
   Sharing an open-source Kafka platform across departments or organizations demands clear usage, ownership, and responsibility guidelines. Without alignment, operational differences can lead to friction.

Examples of open-source Kafka in action
‍

Open-source is already transforming operations across industries. Here are some examples from the energy sector, where real-time data processing is critical:

• TenneT (Dutch TSO)some text
  • Tech Stack: Open-source with governance tooling (on-prem)
  • Use Cases: Real-time alarming, data-as-a-product initiatives, decision support, and cloud transformation.
• Alliander (Dutch DSO)some text
  • Tech Stack: Open-source Kafka with Strimzi and governance tooling (on-prem)
  • Use Cases: IT/OT data center integration, recently transitioned from vendor-locked Kafka to open-source.
• Enexis (Dutch DSO)some text
  • Tech Stack: Open-source Kafka and governance tooling (cloud)
  • Use Cases: Smart meter lifecycle management, data sharing with external systems, and BI system integration.
• Stedin (Dutch DSO)some text
  • Tech Stack: Open-source Kafka and governance tooling (on-prem)
  • Use Cases: Data collection from 20,000 smart grid devices, digital twin creation, and SCADA system integration

While these examples highlight successes in the energy sector, the benefits of open-source Kafka extend to other industries, including finance, healthcare, and retail.

Migration strategy for moving from vendor lock-in to open-source event streaming

Transitioning from a vendor lock-in to an open-source event streaming platform is a significant undertaking. To ensure a smooth migration, organizations must develop a well-defined strategy that addresses the technical, operational, and security aspects of the transition. Below, we outline key considerations and steps to help plan and execute a successful Kafka migration.

1. Plan for producers, consumers, and data migration
‍‍

At the core of Kafka are the producers and consumers that interact with your topics, as well as the data these topics contain. A successful migration involves ensuring seamless transitions for all three:

• Producers: Evaluate how your current producers interact with the Kafka cluster. Identify any custom logic or configurations that need to be replicated in the open-source environment. Implement and test producers in the new environment before decommissioning the old setup.
• Consumers: Consumers often rely on specific offsets and partitions to read data. During migration, ensure that these offsets are maintained to avoid processing duplicate or missing data. Consider tools or strategies like dual writes or bridge clusters to facilitate a phased migration.
• Data migration: Assess the volume of data within your Kafka topics and determine the most efficient way to migrate it. Options include using tools like Kafka Connect, MirrorMaker, or custom scripts. Prioritize topics with critical, real-time data to minimize operational disruptions.

2. Account for the schema registry

‍The schema registry is a critical component in any Kafka ecosystem, as it governs how data is structured and ensures compatibility between producers and consumers. When migrating:

• Export all existing schemas from your current registry.
• Validate that these schemas are compatible with your new open-source Kafka setup.
• Import schemas into the new environment and test them thoroughly with both producers and consumers to avoid runtime issues.

Failing to account for the schema registry can lead to broken integrations and data inconsistencies, so prioritize this step early in your migration plan.

3. Manage access controls

‍Securely migrating access controls is another essential part of the transition. A clear strategy for managing permissions ensures that only authorized applications and users interact with Kafka topics.

• Audit existing access controls: Start by mapping which applications and teams currently have access to each topic and the level of access (read, write, or admin).
• Replicate permissions: In the open-source environment, set up access controls to mirror the existing setup. Tools like role-based access control (RBAC) can simplify this process.
• Secure migration: During the transition, ensure that sensitive data and credentials are handled securely. Use encryption and secure channels to transfer configurations and settings.
• Test access control: Before going live, thoroughly test the new environment to ensure that all permissions are correctly configured and no unauthorized access is possible.

Join our Online webinar Vendor lock-in to open-source

‍
January 22 at 10:00 AM CEST

Want to know more about how other companies moved to open-source Kafka. Join us for an insightful webinar, Alliander's Path from Kafka Vendor Lock-In to Open-Source, hosted by Alliander and Axual. On January 22 at 10:00 AM CEST, we'll dive into Alliander's journey of transitioning from a vendor-locked Kafka implementation to a flexible, open-source solution. Learn from real-world experiences, discover key challenges, and gain valuable insights into how open-source Kafka can help your organization achieve greater flexibility and independence. Don’t miss this opportunity to hear directly from industry expert Erik Lindeman.

Get your seat now

Closing thoughts

The transition from vendor-locked Kafka to open-source is a bold move that offers unmatched flexibility and independence. However, success requires careful planning, investment in expertise, and robust governance practices to manage the challenges that come with the shift.

Whether in energy, finance, or any other sector, open-source Kafka represents an opportunity to build a future-proof, scalable, and collaborative data ecosystem. If your organization is considering this journey, take the time to evaluate both the opportunities and the challenges and equip your teams with the tools and knowledge needed to succeed.

Let’s explore how open-source Kafka can help your organization achieve its goals.

‍